Why Boston’s Controversial Abraham Lincoln Statue Is Still Hidden Away Years After Its Removal

It has been almost six years since the City of Boston removed the Emancipation Group monument, also known as the Emancipation Memorial, from Park Square due to concerns about what some perceived to be its racist imagery.

The statue is a replica of a bronze Thomas Ball sculpture erected in Lincoln Park, Washington, D.C. in 1876. The Boston replica was installed in 1879 and remained in place until being removed on December 29, 2020.

The City of Boston website says the original artwork "aimed to commemorate the Emancipation Proclamation and honor President Lincoln." The site says, "The original version was funded by donations from formerly enslaved people."

Boston's Emancipation Memorial Still In Storage Six Years After Removal

A History Rooted in 1876 and Frederick Douglass's Critique

"Abolitionist Frederick Douglass spoke at the dedication in Washington," according to the City website. "Douglass later stated his disappointment in the monument's portrayal of its Black subject and Emancipation."

Douglass spent several years in New Bedford after escaping from bondage. A statue and tribute to Douglass is part of New Bedford's Abolition Row Park.

Why Boston Removed the Park Square Statue in 2020

While the original Emancipation Memorial remains in Lincoln Park in Washington, D.C, the Boston replica was removed and placed in storage following a public outcry over its depiction of a formerly enslaved Black man kneeling before Lincoln, who holds the Emancipation Proclamation in his hand.

What’s Next for the Monument? Search for a New Location

The City of Boston is said to be seeking a "suitable location" to display the artwork in a way that its context can be better explained. The City is seeking suggestions as to a more suitable site to place the statue.

There is no indication of a timetable for relocating the Emancipation Memorial.